Criminal Case Settlement vs. Trial: Making the Right Choice

How to Know If Settlement or Trial is Right for Your Criminal Case

Making the Crucial Decision That Can Shape Your Future

Facing a criminal case can be one of the most challenging and uncertain times in your life. You’re likely wrestling with questions like, “Should I seek a settlement or go to trial?” This decision can profoundly impact your future, freedom, and reputation.

At the Law Firm of Steven Gacovino, we understand the complexities of criminal cases and are here to guide you toward the best choice for your unique situation. In this comprehensive guide, we’ll provide insights, statistics, and expert advice to help you determine whether a criminal case settlement or trial is the right path for you.

The Power of Criminal Case Settlements: Navigating Toward Resolution

Regarding criminal cases, settlements offer a route to resolution that can save time, money, and emotional stress. Here are some compelling reasons why you might consider a criminal case settlement:

1. Faster Resolution: According to the Bureau of Justice Statistics, the median time from arrest to the disposition of a felony case in U.S. courts is around 146 days. In contrast, settlements often lead to quicker resolutions, sparing you from prolonged legal battles.

2. Cost Savings: Legal fees, court expenses, and time away from work can all add up during a trial. The U.S. Department of Justice reports that the average cost of a federal criminal trial in 2018 was over $180,000. Settling may provide significant cost savings.

3. Reduced Uncertainty: Trials are inherently uncertain, with outcomes that can be unpredictable. By opting for a settlement, you gain more control over the outcome and can avoid the risk of a harsher sentence.

The Strength of Criminal Trials: Fighting for Your Rights

Criminal Case Settlement vs. Trial - Making the Right Choice

On the other hand, criminal trials can be the right choice in certain situations. Here’s why you might want to consider going to trial:

1. Innocence Assertion: If you believe in your innocence and have strong evidence, a trial may be the best way to prove your case and clear your name.

2. Negotiation Leverage: Sometimes, the prosecution’s willingness to negotiate a favorable settlement hinge on their belief that they are prepared to go to trial. A strong defense can tip the scales in your favor during negotiations.

3. Public Perception: Trials can offer an opportunity to present your side of the story to the public, potentially shaping public opinion in your favor.

Making the Decision: Your Path to Justice

So, how do you determine whether a criminal case settlement or trial is the right choice for your situation? Here are some crucial steps to help you decide:

1. Consult a Legal Expert: Reach out to the experienced attorneys at the Law Firm of Steven Gacovino for a thorough evaluation of your case. We’ll assess the evidence, legal options, and potential outcomes to help you make an informed decision.

2. Consider Your Goals: Consider what you hope to achieve with your case. Do you seek retribution, reduced sentencing, or a quick resolution? Your goals will influence your choice.

3. Assess the Evidence: The strength of the evidence for and against you plays a critical role. A strong case might lead to a favorable trial outcome, while weak evidence may push you toward a settlement.

Your future hangs in the balance. Don’t face your criminal case alone. At the Law Firm of Steven Gacovino, we’re here to provide the guidance and support you need. 

Take the first step toward compensation and justice.

Schedule a consultation today with Ramon Cabrera at, and let him fight for you and protect your rights. Call (631) 609-4500 or fill out the contact form at


Contact Us

270 W Main Street
Sayville, NY 11782

Phone: (631) 609-4500



Attorney Advertising Legal Disclaimer – Admitted in NY, NJ, CT, and Washington, D.C. only. While this firm maintains joint responsibility, your case may be referred to local or trial counsel for primary handling. Not available in all states. Prior results cannot and do not guarantee or predict a similar outcome with respect to any future matter, including yours, in which a lawyer or law firm may be retained.

Copyright© 2024, Law Offices Of Steven Gacovino. All Rights Reserved.